1- Indian
Child Abuse Neglect & Child Labour (ICANCL) Group, New Delhi, India.
2- International
Centre for Missing & Exploited Children(ICMEC), Virginia, USA.
3- National
Institute of Mental Health and Neurosciences (NIMHANS), Bangalore, India.
Background: Pediatricians are likely to encounter children who have suffered instances of abuse and neglect on account of societal changes due to the COVID-19pandemic. There is an urgent need to up skill paediatricians on recognising and responding to cases of child abuse and neglect (CAN) in the Indian context. In this document, the term “abuse” refers to physical, emotional, sexual abuse and neglect and a child refers to an individual below the age of 18years.
Aims: To assist and provide resources to pediatricians and allied medical professionals to help recognize and respond to suspected cases of CAN during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Methods: The executive board of the Indian Child Abuse Neglect and Child Labour (ICANCL) group of Indian Academy of Pediatrics (IAP) approved a series of meetings with a working group of multidisciplinary medical professionals to address the impact of the pandemic on children. The group framed guidelines after extensive testing in clinical setups, discussions, and iterations.
Results: COVID-19 specific guidelines on recognition and response to CAN were formatted into flowcharts for ease in comprehension and execution.
Conclusions: The pandemic has dramatically increased the potential for violence, abuse and neglect in vulnerable children’s lives in India. The pandemic also has impacted the lives of parents, many of whom have lost livelihoods or been challenged by physical and mental health issues that adversely affect the lives of their children at home. Screening and assessment of CAN by paediatricians is therefore essential in prevention and early intervention to protect children’s safety.
Keywords: Child abuse and
neglect (CAN), guidelines, pediatrician, pandemic
INTRODUCTION
Child abuse and neglect
is a serious, widely prevalent, yet under-reported public health problem in
India [1]. In this document, the term “abuse” refers to
physical, emotional, sexual abuse and neglect and a child refers to an
individual below the age of 18 years [2]. Estimates of the prevalence of child sexual
abuse (CSA) range from 4-41%, depending on the sample population, definition of
CSA and method of measurement considered [3]. In a study of adolescent students
in Kerala, lifetime prevalence of abuse was high, with 73.9% of youth reporting
physical abuse, 73.4% endorsing emotional abuse; 66.9% reporting neglect and
19.9% reporting sexual abuse [4]. Child abuse exerts a multitude of short- and
long-term health effects on children, which may include serious and often
lifelong adverse consequences to their mental, physical, and reproductive
health, academic performance, and social functioning.
Pediatricians and other health professionals are
often the first point of contact for abused and neglected children [5,6]. They
play a key role in detecting child abuse and providing immediate and long-term
care and support to children [7,8].
Adverse health effects of various forms of child abuse may range from
mild bruising to fatal head injury, inflicted burns, sexually transmitted
infections, HIV/AIDS, unwanted pregnancy, post-traumatic stress disorder, major
depression and suicide, anxiety disorders and substance misuse [9,10,11].
India has been affected by the second highest burden of
Coronavirus (COVID-19) infections in the world [12]. The lockdown measures
mandated by the Indian Government to contain the pandemic have led to losses of
livelihood and income for millions of informal labourers, migrants, and daily
wage workers [13]. Due to closure of schools, limited movements outside their
homes and anticipated COVID-19preventive measures, children and young people
are experiencing heightened adversities [13, 14]. Children in marginalized communities are made
more vulnerable due to food insecurity, malnutrition, and limited access to
health services, and routine immunizations [13,15].
CHILDLINE, an Indian national hotline (Telephone 1098) for
children and families in distress, received 4,392, 772 calls during the initial
period of the COVID-19lockdown in India (April to September 202
Given major concerns regarding child violence
and exploitation within the context of the COVID-19and future pandemics, the
executive board of the Indian Child Abuse and Neglect and Child Labour (ICANCL)
Group of the Indian Academy of Pediatrics (IAP) convened a series of meetings
with experts to create recommendations for pediatricians that will assist them
in preventing, recognizing, and responding to child abuse and neglect during
and after the period ofCOVID-19pandemiclockdown [21]. The meetings occurred
from July 2020 to March2021 and were attended by academic and practicing
pediatricians, child abuse specialists, child development, adolescent and
forensic medicine specialists, child psychiatry, psychologist, and medical
administrators. Due to the COVID restrictions and the need for a quick
screening, the expert consensus was to frame simple and brief guidelines that
could be easily implemented in clinical practice.
AIMS AND OBJECTIVES
The present ICANCL group, IAP guidelines that follow are
intended to assist pediatricians and allied medical professionals in
In the context of this document the
term “abuse” refers to physical,
emotional, sexual abuse and neglect and a child refers to an individual up to
and including18 years of age.
METHODS
Development of Guideline for
Screening
A series of 15 consultative expert group meetings were
conducted during the pandemic keeping in mind the impact of the pandemic on the
lives of children. The meetings occurred from July 2020 to March 2021 and
included executive board members of ICANCL group.The guidelines were formulated
with a variant of the focus group discussion in addition to the Delphi method.
The discussions involved a range of medical professionals who framed guidelines
after extensively reviewing their scope of implementation in a variety of
setups including but not limited to private practice clinics, private
hospitals, medical colleges,and governmental hospitals. Pediatricians across
the country working in these set ups were consulted regarding the practical
feasibility of the guidelines. Feedback received from the field was
incorporated to refine and simplify the guidelines to suit a range of settings.
RESULTS
Approach to screening for COVID-19 related Stress and Child Protection
Risks
It
is essential to build rapport with the child and
caregiver before initiating conversations of sensitive topics. The healthcare
provider should:
The
screening process is summarized in Figure 1. It is recommended that all
children and/or their caregivers who attend a health facility be screened for
CAN by asking probe and qualifier questions. When screening a child,
adolescent, or adult caregiver, the pediatrician should ask open-ended, non-leading
questions to explore any concerns that are voiced. (“Can you tell me more about that? Help me understand….”) Direct questions may be used to address
specific details that are not forthcoming in the patient/caregiver narrative
but should be followed by a return to open-ended questions (“You mentioned the
child’s father has become violent. When
was the last time this happened? (direct question) ….” “I see”). “Tell me more about that episode.” (open
ended question).
The
algorithm/flowchart in Figure 2 outlines the brief screening and immediate
management process for caregivers of young children (<10 years) or those
with disabilities. Figure 3 describes
the process for screening older children (>10 years) and younger
children with concerns of CAN (5-10 years).
The screen should be done outside the presence of the caregiver in order
to allow the child/adolescent to feel comfortable sharing concerns.
The
clinician should maintain a non-judgmental, calm demeanour and engage in active
listening (maintain eye contact, nod, occasionally repeat back a few words that
have been said to demonstrate listening).
They should acknowledge and appreciate child/caregiver insight and
positive coping skills and reassure that they are available to help. The provider may then engage the individual
in problem-solving to address concerns.
It is helpful to begin by asking the child or caregiver for their
opinion about what they think may be helpful before offering additional ideas
and resources. The clinician may provide directed anticipatory guidance on
positive parenting, internet safety, or strategies for stress reduction and
emotional regulation; for example, local and national resources may be offered
in the form of online information and brochures. Specific resources may be found in this
document. Health professionals
throughout India should offer caregivers and children the hotline number for
CHILDLINE (1098) and provide information about this comprehensive resource
[16]. CHILDLINE provides emergency
assistance for children facing violence, sexual abuse, exploitation, or
neglect, as well as families in need of basic assistance during the
COVID-19pandemic (e.g., food, shelter, access to health care). Clinicians need to be familiar with CHILDLINE
and all it has to offer. Posters and
brochures may be helpful in providing this information to families.
The limits of confidentiality should be explained before
beginning a discussion of sensitive issues which may lead to mandatory
reporting (for instance in case of suspected sexual abuse). Using a
developmentally appropriate approach, the clinician may inform the child that
authorities must be notified if information is revealed that indicates harm has
been done to the child or to others (or may be done in future) or laws have
been violated. The child should also understand that the information would then
be shared with an adult whom the child trusts. Confidentiality cannot be
maintained when the child reveals sexual abuse, criminal behaviour, suicidal
behaviour or when hospitalisation is indicated. According to the Protection of
Children from Sexual Offences Act (POCSO) it is mandatory to report all cases
of CSA to the police [22].
In some cases, a child may be experiencing significant
mental health issues that require additional counselling. If the clinician is experienced in providing
this counselling an appointment can be made to engage in further
discussion. Alternatively, the provider
may wish to refer the child to a mental health professional. A toll-free hotline to the National Institute
of Mental Health and Neurosciences (NIMHANS) may be useful (0804611007) [23].
When screening adolescents, the
clinician may refer to some or all the questions included in the HEEADSSS
psychosocial assessment (see Table 1)[24].
It is helpful to inquire about problems during the pandemic related to
home, nutrition, schooling, media, mental well-being, and safety. A physical,
systemic, and mental status examination should be conducted. Possible
indicators of CAN on physical examination are given in Table 2. If there are
red flag signs of psychoses, suicidal behaviour or severe mental disorder, the
child should be immediately referred to a mental health professional.
If abuse is suspected and the safety of the child may be compromised, a detailed safety plan should be discussed with the non-abusing caregiver to ensure physical and psychosocial well-being. Concerns of sexual abuse should be referred to authorities per the POCSO Act [22]. The caregiver and child should be made aware of the requirements of mandatory reporting. If patient or caregiver voice concerns about reporting, these should be acknowledged and explored by the clinician, and the provider should reiterate the reasons for reporting (e.g., the safety of the child and other potential victims). The clinician should also explain that while a report must be made to law enforcement, the child/caregiver is not required to pursue an investigation.
Figure 1: Summary of the screening process
Figure 2: Algorithm of Brie Screening and Assistance for Caregivers)
Figure 3:
Algorithm of Brief Screening and Immediate Assistance for Children and
Adolescents
Recognizing and Responding to
Suspected Child Maltreatment
In partnership with
UNICEF, the ICANCL group created a reference handbook “Child Abuse: Recognition and Response” for pediatricians and
medical professionals [27]. The handbook provides basic knowledge, current
guidelines, and a Standard Operating Protocol (SOP) for prompt recognition and
management of survivors of child abuse. Additional comprehensive guidelines
exist to assist clinicians to recognize and appropriately respond to child
maltreatment [28,29,30].
The response to CSA is both nuanced
and complicated due to the complex interplay of psychological and social
processes involved in this form of abuse. Therefore, guidelines for CSA
necessitate mental health and multidisciplinary professionals to work with many
processes and systems to effectively assist the child. The Protection of
Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act (2012) is a comprehensive law which
makes reporting of CSA mandatory and defines guidelines for child friendly
police and court procedures [22,].
Table
1: Examples of Screening Questions based on HEEADSSS framework [24].
Home: |
Education/
Employment: |
Eating:
|
Activities: |
Drugs and Alcohol
use: |
Sexuality:
|
Suicide/Depression:
|
Safety: |
Pediatricians and allied
professionals should discuss with the child and caregiver as appropriate, to
maintain transparency and trust.
Exceptions to this may occur if the child is not able to understand due
to developmental or medical issues, or if the caregiver is a suspected
offender. In managing these
circumstances, it is always best to make the child’s best interest the highest
priority. Emergency and therapeutic
medical care must be provided in all case of CSA, even in absence of police or
magisterial requisition.
In cases of suspected CSA, informed consent/assent must be
obtained from caregiver and patient before conducting a medical evaluation of
CSA, collecting samples for forensic examination, performing diagnostic
testing, and offering treatment. If the child is over 12 years of age, consent
should be sought from the child. For those below the age of 12 years, a parent
or the guardian is required to provide it. The person obtaining the consent
should clearly explain the purpose of each process, as well as potential risks,
benefits, possible adverse effects, and approximate amount of time required
[31]. Police personnel should not be present during any part of the
examination. Where the victim is a girl, the medical examination should be
conducted by a woman doctor in the presence of the non-offending parent of the
child or any other person in whom the child reposes trust or confidence (child
should choose). If such a person cannot be present, the examination is
conducted in the presence of a woman nominated by the head of the medical
institution. Detailed,
well-documented medical records must be kept.
Treatment of sexually transmitted diseases (STIs), emotional support and
referrals to multidisciplinary team should be made as indicated.
Table 2: Potential Indicators of
Sexual and/or Physical Abuse* [25,26]
Nonspecific Signs/Symptoms of
Traumatic Stress |
·
Sudden changes in behavior ·
Chronic pain without obvious source ·
Change in eating patterns. ·
Sleep problems ·
Interpersonal problems (e.g., withdrawal, aggression; avoidance) ·
Decrease in academic performance. ·
Anxiety, poor concentration ·
Dissociative symptoms ·
Problematic sexual behavior ·
Depression, self-harm behavior ·
Difficulty controlling emotions |
Sexual Abuse |
·
Symptoms/signs of sexually transmitted infection ·
Anogenital trauma ·
Pregnancy (in specific contexts) |
Physical Abuse |
·
Injuries in ordinarily protected areas of body (e.g., ears, neck,
torso, upper arms, upper, medial, or posterior thighs, genitalia, buttocks,
feet) ·
Patterned injuries (reproduce shape of impacting object) ·
Explanation of injury that is: o
Inconsistent with child’s developmental capabilities o
Inconsistent with mechanism or appearance of injury o Changing over time or
between caregivers |
REPORTING
PROCEDURES
The Ministry of Women and Child Development, Government of India is as the apex
body for administration of the rules, regulations and laws relating to women
and children [32,33]. The National Commission for the Protection of Child
Rights (NCPCR) is an Indian statutory body established by an act of the
Parliament, the Commission of Protection of Child Rights (2005) [34]. The NCPCR
works under the aegis of the Ministry of WCD under the Government of India.
Each Indian state/Union Territory has a State Commission for the Protection of
Child Rights(SCPCR) to implement and monitor child rights and protection
programs The NCPCR has recently introduced Protection
of Children from Sexual Offences Act (POCSO) E-box on
its website (www.ncpcr.gov.in) for anyone to anonymously
report complaints of child abuse [22].The Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act
(JJ Act 2015) is the primary legal framework for juvenile justice in India,
that establishes a framework for both Children who are in conflict with law (CCL) and Children in
need of care and protection (CNCP) [33]. The JJ Act ensures proper care, protection, development, treatment, and
social re-integration of children in difficult circumstances by adopting a
child - friendly approach keeping in view the best interest of the child. Each district has a District Child
Protection Unit (DCPU), in which there are juvenile justice boards (JJB), child
welfare committees (CWC) and special juvenile police units (SJPU). Every block (city ward) and every village
have a Child Protection Committee to monitor child protection services at the
local level. Pediatricians should have easy access and maintain contact
information of these services in their regions.
The ICANCL Group, IAP has collaborated with the
International Centre for Missing and Exploited Children (ICMEC), USA, and
developed an Indian Child Protection Medical Professional Network (ICPMPN)
(2017-present) [35,36]. The ICPMPN is comprised of a network of pediatricians
and allied medical doctors from across India, who are trained on the medical
management of child sexual abuse and exploitation. The goal of the network is
to increase accessibility to medical services for abused children and their
families and improve the quality of medical evaluations for suspected victims
of child sexual abuse. Community providers may contact network members to ask
questions about CAN and register for trainings on abuse awareness and response
[36].
Strategies for Prevention and
Intervention in Suspected Child
Pediatricians
play an important role in advocating for the health and well-being of children
and their families. This role is especially important during the course of
the pandemic. Primary prevention of child abuse and neglect is
integral to keeping children safe and healthy.
Practitioners may take one or more of the following steps to help
prevent child abuse and neglect during the COVID-19pandemic:
Pediatricians and allied health professionals have an
important role to play in preventing, recognizing, and responding to suspected
child abuse. During the extremely
stressful times surrounding the COVID-19 pandemic, the risk for CAN is likely
to be elevated, and health care providers have a duty to screen for family
stressors and potential abuse. Simple
qualifier and probe questions should be asked of caregivers and age-appropriate
children, to open the door for discussions of concerns related to abuse. Using a supportive, non-judgmental approach,
the provider can explore the concerns, offer anticipatory guidance and
resources, and make necessary mandatory reports as appropriate.
CONFLICT
OF INTERESTS: None
FUNDING
SOURCE: None
Disclaimer: The
recommendations are the opinion of the participating experts to guide
pediatricians to screen for and assist in recognizing and responding to cases
of child abuse and neglect (CAN) in Indian settings during the times of
COVID-19 Pandemic. These are neither binding, nor the only possible actions;
individual practice may deviate from these depending on the situation in an
individual case or the existing laws.