Background: There is an increasing incidence of pediatric
acute pancreatitis worldwide. Determining local data on clinical profile,
factors, severity and outcome would help improve recognition, diagnosis and
management of this emerging disease.
Aim: To determine the clinical profile of Pediatric Acute
Pancreatitis and the factors associated with their outcome and severity.
Methods: A retrospective chart review of children 0-18 years old
with diagnosis of Acute Pancreatitis was done. Demographic, clinical and
diagnostic data gathered were compared among severity classification and outcome.
Results: Thirty-five cases were identified in a period of 18 years
but only 28 were reviewed. Mean age was 11.5 years old +/- 4.1 SD (range 4–18) with
slight male predominance. Ninety-three percent presented with abdominal pain.
Most common etiology was idiopathic (44%). Gallstones and choledochal cyst
post-excision were the most common of the co-morbidities. Most common imaging
findings were edematous pancreas. Most common local complications were
pseudocyst formation and fluid collection. One death was due to hemorrhagic
pancreatitis. Gallstones was associated with non-mild severity classification
(p<0.028) and 3-10 years age group with incomplete enzymatic/radiologic
resolution upon discharge (p<0.04).
Conclusion:
Presence of gallstones and 3-10 years old age group were found to affect
severity and outcome and should be viewed closely during management of
pediatric acute pancreatitis.
Recommendation: A multi-center study on the incidence, clinical profile and outcome is recommended to obtain a better picture of the acute pancreatitis in Filipino children to help clinicians in recognizing and decreasing the morbidity and mortality of this disease.
Keywords: Acute Pancreatitis, Filipino children, severity, outcome, pediatric pancreatitis
INTRODUCTION
Different authors worldwide
reported the increasing incidence of Pancreatitis in children [1,2,3].
Pancreatitis results from an insult to the pancreas leading to acute
inflammatory changes, edema and necrosis that may lead to organ damage or
fibrosis [4]. Data in children is limited to retrospective studies and current
management is largely based from adult literature. In the Philippines, only one
retrospective study on Childhood Pancreatitis was done in a tertiary government
hospital from 2005-2009 with 23 cases included [5].
Factors that are
associated with a more severe course of pancreatitis need to be recognized to
optimize the clinician’s approach and minimize complications and prevent
mortality. This paper aims to describe the clinical profile of Filipino pediatric
patients diagnosed with Acute Pancreatitis admitted in a tertiary hospital and
to establish possible factors that might predict severity and outcome of the
disease.
METHODOLOGY
This was a retrospective chart review done
among Filipino children 0 to 18 years old admitted at a tertiary hospital with
a discharge diagnosis of Acute Pancreatitis from January 2000 up to December
2017. Acute Pancreatitis (AP) was defined as having at least 2 out of 3 criteria
[6]: (a) Abdominal pain suggestive of, or compatible with AP (i.e. abdominal
pain of acute onset, especially in the epigastric region) (b) Serum amylase
and/or lipase activity at least 3 times greater than the upper limit of normal
(international unit/liter), and, (c) Imaging findings characteristic of, or
compatible with AP (e.g. using Ultrasonography, Contrast-enhanced computed
tomography, endoscopic ultrasonography, magnetic resonance imaging/magnetic
resonance cholangiopancreatography). Acute
Recurrent Pancreatitis was defined as having at least 2 distinct episodes of Acute
Pancreatitis, along with: (a) Complete resolution of pain ≥ 1-month pain-free
interval between diagnoses of Acute Pancreatitis, OR, (b) Complete
normalization of serum pancreatic enzyme levels (amylase and lipase), before
the subsequent episode of Acute Pancreatitis is diagnosed, along with complete
resolution of pain symptoms, irrespective of a specific time interval between
Acute Pancreatitis episode [6].
There were 35 cases
with ICD-10 code K95 pertaining to Acute Pancreatitis. Of these, only 32 charts
were retrieved with 3 charts during 2001-2005 not recovered. Among the 32
cases, 2 were excluded due to early discharge (transferred to another hospital
and opted home against medical advice) and 2 cases did not fulfill the criteria
for Acute Pancreatitis. Twenty- eight (28) charts were reviewed with a dropout
rate of 20%. Among the 28 charts reviewed, there were 5 patients who was
classified as Acute Recurrent Pancreatitis with 4 readmissions and 1 new
admission. Thus, observations referred to number of cases or admissions (N=28),
but total number of patients was 24.
Outcomes includes
severity of disease as mild, moderately severe or severe, which is based from
classification by North American Society for Pediatric Gastroenterology,
Hepatology and Nutrition (NASPGHAN) Pancreas Committee for Acute Pediatric
Pancreatitis [7]:
(1)
Pediatric Mild AP is defined as AP not is not associated with any organ
failure, local or systemic complications, and usually resolves within the first
week after presentation
(2)
Pediatric Moderate Severe AP is defined as AP with either the
development of transient organ failure/dysfunction (lasting no >48 hours) or
development of local or systemic complications.
(3)
Pediatric Severe AP is defined as AP with development of organ
dysfunction that persists >48 hours.
Outcomes of clinical improvement with and without resolution of enzymatic and/or imaging findings, and death were recorded.
Descriptive analysis was done with categorical variables presented as frequencies and percentages, while continuous variables as either means with standard deviations (SDs) or as medians for non-parametric data. Statistical analysis was performed by comparing categorical variables using Fisher’s exact t test, while Mann Whitney test and ANOVA were used for continuous predictor variable. Data were compiled and analyzed using Stata 10 (StataCorp, TX). P<0.05 was considered statistically significant.
Bioethical considerations
The study was
conducted in compliance with the principles set out in relevant guidelines
including the Declaration of Helsinksi, World Health Organization guidelines,
International Conference on Harmonization-Good Clinical Practice and National
Ethics Guidelines for Health Research. The study protocol was approved by the
Institutional Review Board of the Philippine Children’s Medical Center with
approval code of PCMC 2017-074. Confidentiality of records was observed
throughout the research period. The principal investigator had no conflict of
interest during the conduct of the study.
RESULTS
Patient characteristics
The medical records of
28 cases with discharge diagnosis of Acute Pancreatitis were reviewed (Table 1).
There were slightly more males (n=15, 54%) than females with a mean age of 11.5
years old +/- 4.1 SD (range 4 – 18). Most of the cases
(61%) belonged to the adolescent group of 11-18 years old. More than half had
malnutrition (n=15, 54%), combined under- and over-nutrition. Sex and
nutritional status showed no statistical significance between the two age
groups (p=0.700, p=0.898, respectively).
Table 1. Demographics
and clinical characteristics according to age group
Age group, n |
Total N=28 |
3-10 years
old n=11 |
11-18 years
old n = 17 |
P value |
Gender Male
Female
|
15 (54%) 13 (46%) |
5 (45%) 6 (55%) |
10 (59%) 7 (41%) |
0.700 |
Nutritional status Normal Overweight and obese Wasting and severe wasting |
13 (46%) 10 (36%) 5 (18%)
|
5 (46%) 4 (36%) 2 (18%) |
8 (47%) 6 (35%) 3 (18%) |
0.898 |
Presenting Symptom Abdominal pain Vomiting |
26 (93%) 2 (7%) |
9 (82%) 2 (18%) |
17 (100%) 0 |
0.146 |
With co-morbid condition |
9 (32%) |
5 (45%) |
4 (23%) |
0.409 |
Etiology Idiopathic Biliary disease Infection Metabolic Multisystem disease Medication Alcohol |
12 (44%) 6 (21%) 6 (21%) 1 (4%) 1 (4%) 1 (4%) 1 (4%) |
4 (37%) 2 (18%) 3 (27%) 0 1 (9%) 1 (9%) 0 |
8 (47%) 4 (23%) 3 (18%) 1 (6%) 0 0 1 (6%) |
0.721 |
Almost all (93%) of
the cases presented with abdominal pain with only 2 cases presenting with
vomiting (7%). Both cases of vomiting were noted in the younger children group.
Age group was not significantly associated with the presenting symptom
(p=0.146). About half (46%) of those who presented with abdominal pain had
associated vomiting. Other symptoms seen
were jaundice (n=2), fever (n=2) and anorexia (n=2). Median time of occurrence
of symptom to admission was 1 day.
One-third (n=9, 32%)
of cases had co-morbidities, as shown in Table 1, and that almost half of the
co-morbidities are of Hepatobiliary diseases such as 2 cases of
Cholecystolithiasis and 2 cases of Choledochal cyst s/p excision. There were 2
oncologic cases (Acute Lymphoblastic Leukemia and Ewing’s sarcoma), 2
neurologic conditions (Epilepsy) and 1 cardiac case (Atrial Septal Defect s/p
repair).
Majority of the cases
(n=12, 42%) had no recognized cause for pancreatitis and was classified as
Idiopathic. There were 6 cases (21%) caused by Biliary diseases such as
choledochal cyst, cholecystolithiasis and cholelithiasis. Another 6 cases (21%)
were associated with infection such as mumps in 2 cases, intestinal parasitism,
urosepsis and pneumonia. There was one case each with associated drug intake
(Valproic acid), alcohol binge, metabolic (hypertriglyceridemia), and a
multisystemic disease (febrile neutropenia, multiorgan involvement).
Radiographic
Presentation
Twenty-four of cases
had at least one imaging technique done. Of those with radiologic
investigation, majority had ultrasonography, two cases had a computed tomography
scan and one had both imaging modality done.
Out of the 24 imaging
studies done, nine had normal findings. Half had findings suggestive of
pancreatitis. Most common finding noted was that of an
edematous/thickened/prominent pancreas seen in 8 cases. Biliary diseases (cholecystitis, cholelithiasis,
cholecystolithiasis), were seen in 5 cases. Other findings were pancreatic or
peripancreatic pseudocyst seen in 3 cases and a finding of phlegmonous pancreas.
Complications and
severity of Acute Pancreatitis and associations with clinical factors,
biochemical, radiographic presentation and management
Complications in Acute
Pancreatitis were classified as either local or systemic complications [8].
Local complications involve the development of peri- or pancreatic
complications including fluid collections or necrosis. Based on the imaging
done, there were 7 cases with local complications including 3 cases each of pseudocysts
and peripancreatic fluid collections and a case of phlegmonous pancreas. On the
other hand, systemic complications are defined as exacerbations of previously
diagnosed co-morbid disease. In this study, there was one case of Acute
Lymphocytic Leukemia who developed Febrile Neutropenia, pleural effusion and
sepsis.
Majority of the cases
were classified under Mild AP (n=20, 71%), while one-fourth was Moderately
Severe AP (n=7, 25%) and only one has Severe AP (n=1, 4%). Since only one case
of severe AP was noted in this study, grouping was described as being Mild or
Non-mild AP, with Non-mild AP being those Moderately Severe and Severe AP. Table
2 showed that age group, sex, nutritional status, presence of co-morbidities,
etiology, biochemical presentation, timing of initiation of feeding, length of
hospital stay and outcome were not significantly associated with severity.
There was significant association in terms of imaging classification as normal,
with findings indicating pancreatitis, and findings pertaining to other organs
among mild and non-mild Acute Pancreatitis (p=0.012).
Looking into the
individual imaging findings showed a statistically significant association
between presence of peri-/pancreatic fluid collections/pseudocyst/ phlegmon
(p=0.000) and the presence of gallstones (p=0.028) and severity. Regression
analysis was not done due to a small size, that joint effect of variation may
be accurately assessed.
Table 2. Association of clinical, biochemical,
radiographic factors with severity of disease
Mild Acute
Pancreatitis (n=20) |
Non-mild
Acute Pancreatitis (n=8) |
Total |
p value |
|
Age group, n(%) 3-10 years old 11- 18 years old |
8 (40%) 12 (60%) |
3 (38%) 5 (62%) |
11 (39%) 17 (61%) |
1.000 |
Gender, n(%) Male Female |
12 (60%) 8 (40%) |
3 (38%) 5 (62%) |
15 (54%) 13 (46%) |
0.410 |
Nutritional status, n(%) Normal Overweight & Obese Moderate and Severe wasting |
9 (45%) 6 (21%) 5 (18%) |
4 (50%) 4 (50%) 0 |
13 (46%) 10 (25%) 5 (11%) |
0.356 |
Presence of co-morbidities, n(%) |
4 (20%) |
5 (62%) |
9 (32%) |
0.068 |
Etiology, n(%) Idiopathic Biliary disease Infection Metabolic Multisystem disease Medication Alcohol |
10 (50%) 4 (20%) 5 (25%) 1 (5%) 1 (5%) 1 (5%) 1 (5%) |
2 (25%) 2 (25%) 1 (13%) 0 (%) 0 (%) 0 (%) 0 (%) |
12 (44%) 6 (21%) 6 (21%) 1 (4%) 1 (4%) 1 (4%) 1 (4%) |
0.919 |
Laboratory Amylase elevation, as median Lipase elevation, as median |
3.9 12.4 |
5.15 8.25 |
n=24 n=21 |
0.5401 0.2935 |
Imaging, n(%) Normal Findings suggestive of pancreatitis* Findings pertaining to other organ+ |
9 (45% 6 (30%) 1 (5%) |
0 6 (75%) 2 (25%) |
9 (32%) 12 (43%) 3 (11%) |
0.012 |
*Findings suggestive of pancreatitis
+Findings pertaining to other organ
|
6 (30%) 0
1 (5%) 1 (5%) 2 (10%) |
2 (25%) 6 (75%)
4 (50%) 3 (37%) 2 (25%) |
8 (29%) 6 (21%)
5 (18%) 4 (14%) 4 (14%) |
0.667 0.000
0.028 0.091 0.578 |
Timing of initiation of feeding, n(%) Early feeding Late feeding |
15 (75%) 5 (25%) |
5 (63%) 3 (37%) |
20 (71%) 8 (29%) |
1.000
|
Length of hospital stay (median, in days) |
6 |
11.5 |
|
0.078 |
Outcome, n(%) Clinical improvement with complete
resolution Clinical improvement without incomplete resolution Mortality |
11 (55% 9 (45%)
0 |
5 (63%) 2 (25%)
1 (12%) |
16 (57%) 11 (39%)
1 (4%) |
0.662 |
Associations of
clinical factors, biochemical, radiographic presentations and management with
outcome on discharge
More than half (n=16,
57%) of the cases were discharged with clinical improvement and complete
enzymatic and/or radiologic resolution. Thirty-nine percent (n=11) was
discharged with incomplete resolution, while 1 has died. Thus, in this study,
mortality rate was computed at 3.6%.
The remaining 27 cases
was discharged clinically improved. Comparison of clinical, biochemical,
radiographic factors and management trends of clinically improved cases upon
discharge among those with complete resolution and incomplete resolution of
enzymatic and/or radiologic parameters was shown in Table 3. The associations
between the factors: sex, nutritional status, presence of co-morbidities,
etiology, biochemical parameters, imaging findings, timing of initiation of
feeding, length of hospital stay and severity (as mild and non-mild) with
having complete versus incomplete enzymatic/radiologic resolution among those
with clinical improvement were not statistically significant. There was
statistically significant difference between age group and the type of clinical
improvement outcome with a p-value of 0.040. However, regression analysis was
not done due to a small size since joint effect of variation may be accurately
assessed.
Table 3.
Association of clinical, biochemical, radiographic factors with outcome of
clinical improvement with complete and incomplete enzymatic/radiologic
resolution
|
Clinical
improvement on discharge |
Total N=27 |
p value |
|
Complete resolution (n=16) |
Incomplete resolution (n=11) |
|||
Age group, n(%) 3-10 years old 11- 18 years old |
3 (19%) 13 (81%) |
7 (64%) 4 (36%) |
10 (37%) 17 (63%) |
0.040 |
Gender, n(%) Male Female |
9 (56%) 7 (44%) |
6 (55%) 5 (45%) |
15 (56%) 12 (48%) |
1.000 |
Nutritional status, n(%) Normal Overweight & Obese Moderate and Severe wasting |
9 (56%) 4 (25%) 3 (19%) |
4 (36%) 5 (45%) 2 (18%) |
13 (48%) 9 (33%) 5 (19%) |
0.599 |
Presence of co-morbidities, n(%) |
4 (25%) |
5 (45%) |
9 (33%) |
0.411 |
Etiology, n(%) Idiopathic Biliary disease Infection Metabolic Multisystem disease Medication Alcohol |
7 (44%) 4 (25%) 3 (19%) 1 (6%) 1 (6%) 0 0 |
4 (36%) 2 (18%) 3 (27%) 0 0 1 (9%) 1 (9%) |
11 (41%) 6 (22%) 6 (22%) 1 (4%) 1 (4%) 1 (4%) 1 (4%) |
0.743 |
Laboratory Amylase elevation, as median Lipase elevation, as median |
6.05 10.5 |
3.15 12.4 |
n=23 n=21 |
0.1014 0.8493 |
Imaging, n(%) Normal Findings suggestive of pancreatitis* Findings pertaining to other organ+ |
5 (31%) 9 (56%) 2 (13%) |
4 (36%) 3 (27%) 0 |
9 (33%) 12 (44%) 2 (7%) |
0.418 |
Timing of initiation of feeding, n(%) Early feeding Late feeding |
8 (50%) 8 (50%) |
6 (55%) 5 (45%) |
14 (52%) 13 (48%) |
1.000
|
Length of hospital stay (median, in days) |
6 |
9 |
|
0.240
|
Severity, n(%) Mild Non-mild |
11 (69%) 5 (31%) |
9 (82%) 2 (18%) |
20 (74%) 7 (26%) |
0.662 |
DISCUSSION
This study reviewed
the cases of Pediatric Acute Pancreatitis admitted in a tertiary institution
over a period of 18 years. Out of the initial 35 cases, 15 cases or 43% were
noted in the first half of the study period (2000-2008) and the remaining 57%
during 2009-2017 representing a 33% rise of admitted cases of AP over the
specified period. Studies worldwide have reported an increasing incidence of
pancreatitis in both children and adults which may reflect a true rise in
number or due to increased awareness of the disease [1,7, 9,10]. Locally, Dizon
et al observed this increased incidence of pancreatitis in children ≤18 years
old in a tertiary referral medical center showing only 5 cases seen from
2000-2004, to 23 cases from 2005-2009 [5].
Twenty-eight cases of
Acute Pancreatitis were reviewed. Age ranges from 4 years old to 18 years old,
with a mean age was 11. 5 years old +/- 4.1 SD. Age groups
was stratified based on a cohort study by Park, et al [11], as infancy,
childhood and adolescence period. In this study, no reports from the infancy
period was seen. This is important to note, since infants manifest fewer
classical signs and symptoms on presentation and less likely to present with
pancreatic enzyme elevations [11] making diagnosis challenging and thus a high
index of suspicion is always warranted. In agreement with the large cohort
study by Park [11], most of the cases were of the adolescent age group. There
was a slight predominance of male sex (1.2:1) in this study. More than half of
cases had malnutrition, comprising mostly of overweight and obese children.
Obesity is a known risk factor of pancreatitis in adults [12,13,14]. In
addition to increasing risk of cholesterol gallstones formation and
gallstone-related complications, the severity of the disease is higher in obese
patients because of specific pathogenic factors, including supersaturated bile
and crystal formation, rapid weight loss and visceral obesity [15]. A study by
Pathak [16] in Hispanic-American children in 2016 found that obesity and
overweight was 7-fold and 6-fold (respectively) likely with pancreatitis as
compared to non-cases. In this study however, there was no statistically
significant difference between nutritional status as well as sex between the
two age groups.
Clinical presentations
seen in this study agreed with most of the known data available [9]. Abdominal
pain as the presenting symptom was seen in 93% of the cases, in agreement with
the proportion noted in a review by Bai et al of 80-95% [9]. In the remaining
cases, vomiting was the presenting symptom, although half of the cases
presenting with abdominal pain had associated vomiting as well. No reports of
bilous vomiting, abdominal distension nor signs of mechanical obstruction was
seen in this study. Symptoms of jaundice and fever were seen which were related
to a co-morbid condition such as gallstones and mumps, respectively.
In one-third of the
admissions, a co-morbid condition was present. This will lead to further
exploration of possible drug-related pancreatitis in oncologic and neurologic
conditions, or biliary-related pancreatitis in those with hepatobiliary
conditions. Hepatobiliary diseases comprised majority of the co-morbidities.
There were 2 cases of choledochal cyst s/p excision who both presented with
abdominal pain without fever, jaundice, nor vomiting. The two other cases had
gallstones with obstructive jaundice.
As reported by a
review by Bai et al, etiology in children are more diverse as compared to adult
population. The top three causes of AP in this study were Idiopathic (43%),
Biliary diseases (21%) and Infection (21%). Biliary tract disease or
obstruction caused by gallbladder sludge, gallstones or tumors comprised 10-30%
of the etiology in acute pancreatitis in children [9]. In this study, there
were 6 cases of biliary disease seen, two with choledochal cyst s/p excision
and hepaticoduodenostomy, and the rest with gallstones. As mentioned,
gallstones are known to cause pancreatitis and is one of the most common causes
of pancreatitis in adults and is related to obesity as well. In children,
however, causes of gallstones vary widely, with obesity, hemolytic anemia, biliary
duct anomaly, infection, ileal disease to name a few [15]. In this study, out
of the 4 cases of gallstones, only 1 was associated with overweight. No
anatomic abnormality was noted based on the limited imaging done, nor other
possible causes of gallstone disease was noted in the chart. Pancreatitis is
one of the possible late complications of choledochal cysts post excision due
to occurrence of post anastomotic strictures [17]. In pediatric pancreatitis,
13-34% would have no recognized cause and be classified as idiopathic [9]. In
this study, almost half were classified as idiopathic. This is one of the major
limitations of a retrospective study, since further inquiry on possible
etiology available to us currently may not done. The local study by Dizon, et
al, reported as well, a high percentage of idiopathic cause (39%) [5]. Six
cases (21%) were associated with infection such as mumps in 2 cases, intestinal
parasitism, urosepsis and pneumonia. As mentioned in the review by Bai, et al,
it was difficult to establish temporal relationship between the infection and
occurrence of pancreatitis. Certain medications are known to cause
pancreatitis. In this study, one case of generalized epilepsy who was on valproic
acid developed pancreatitis. Valproic acid has the highest rate reported in a
series of pediatric pancreatitis [15], although no clear mechanism has been
delineated for such [9]. Moderate hypertriglyceridemia was noted in one case
with triglyceride level of 2.39 mmol/L. A multisystemic disease of Acute Lymphocytic
Leukemia with febrile neutropenia, sepsis and multiorgan dysfunction was seen
in one case. Lastly, one case of alcohol-induced pancreatitis of an 18-year-old
male with history of daily alcohol binge from 6 days prior to appearance of
symptom and admission. In children, hereditary causes comprised 5%-8% of cases
with genetic mutations of the cationic trypsinogen gene (PRSS1), the pancreatic
secretory trypsin inhibitor gene (SPINK1), and the cystic fibrosis
transmembrane conductance regulator gene (CFTR) which are all involved in the
pathogenesis of pancreatitis [9]. Genetic testing for this, however, is not
available locally. It remains to be determined to what extent these mutations
are involved in those with idiopathic causes. It is important to note that
compared to most data on etiology of pediatric pancreatitis, both local and
foreign, trauma cases which comprised 10-40% of etiology, were not seen in this
study. This is probably due to the proximity of our institution to a trauma
center where cases of trauma-induced pancreatitis are possibly redirected.
One of the criteria
for diagnosis of Acute Pancreatitis is the amylase and lipase elevation of at
least 3 times the upper limit of normal [6]. In this study, median elevation of
lipase (11.3 times elevated) was higher than amylase elevation (4.2 times
elevated). Lipase is a known to stay elevated longer than amylase and is useful
in cases of delayed presentation. Several correlation studies of the pancreatic
enzymes showed its poor predictive value for severity of disease [18]. In this
study, a wide range of elevation levels were noted for both enzymes (amylase:
1-28.9 times elevated and lipase 1 – 78.6 times elevated). Levels were compared
in between groups, Mild vs Non-mild severity, and outcome, but found to have no
statistically significant difference (tables 2 and 3). Thus, amylase and lipase
use are purely for establishing diagnosis.
Another criterion for
diagnosis is the radiographic findings suggestive of pancreatic inflammation.
Although not routinely done [18], imaging provides information on possible
etiology such as gallstones (as seen in 5 cases, 21%) and complications, such as
pseudocysts (seen in 3 cases, 21%). In this study, majority had imaging done,
most common is ultrasonography. This is particularly acceptable as an initial
tool in pediatric pancreatitis since no exposure to ionizing radiation is done
and is widely available [9]. It additionally provides information on multiple
causes of an acute abdomen such as volvulus and intussusception. However, the
disadvantage of being operator dependent and overlying bowel case or an obese
patient can obscure investigation on the pancreas. Contrast enhanced computed
tomography (CECT) remains the criterion standard for diagnostic imaging in
pancreatitis [18] but indication may vary since radiation exposure and need to
sedation are limiting considerations in the pediatric population. In this
study, only 3 or 10% underwent CECT. Other imaging modalities, such as magnetic
resonance imaging, magnetic resonance cholangiopancreatography, were not
observed in this study.
Recurrence of
pancreatitis episodes in children has been known to occur in 15%- 35% of
children after an initial episode [18]. However, it was only in 2012 when a
consensus definition of Pediatric-onset Acute Recurrent Pancreatitis (ARP) has
been published [6]. In this study, there were 5 cases classified as Acute
Recurrent Pancreatitis based on this consensus definition. Recurrence rate was
17.8%. As mentioned, these 5 cases reflected 4 patients, since 2 of the cases
here were of the same patient. Majority was female, adolescent and of normal
nutritional status. 2 cases were of idiopathic cause, one associated with
infection, and the last 2 cases were of the same patient who had gallstones.
Additional data on children are being gathered by the INSPPIRE (INternational
Study group of Pediatric Pancreatitis: In search for a cuRE) cohort to know
more of the natural history of the disease, progression of ARP to Chronic
Pancreatitis as well as factors affecting it. Uc, et al recently published
their findings on the impact of obesity on Pediatric ARP and Chronic Pancreatitis
based from the INSPPIRE cohort. They found out that compared with children with
normal weight, obese or overweight children were older at first acute
pancreatitis episode and diagnosed with Chronic pancreatitis at an older age and
thus seems to delay the initial acute pancreatitis episode and diagnosis of CP
compared with normal weight or underweight [14].
In this study, the
median length of hospital stay in acute pancreatitis in children was 8 days.
This agrees with the reported median hospitalization length in large studies
abroad of 5 to 8 days [6]. Management of pediatric pancreatitis centers on
fluid hydration, pain control and optimal nutritional support. Recently, a
recommendation on the management of acute pancreatitis in the pediatric
population was recently published by the North American Society for Pediatric
Gastroenterology, Hepatology and Nutrition (NASPGHAN) Pancreas Committee [18].
Bowel rest or putting
the patient on NPO (nil per os) has
traditionally been the conventional practice in pancreatitis in the aim of
suppressing pancreatic enzyme secretion thus healing pancreas more rapidly.
However, recent evidences have consistently demonstrated that this approach may
lead to increased risk of infectious complications coming from bacterial
overgrowth and translocation the gut and thereby resulting to higher morbidity
and mortality in cases of severe acute pancreatitis [19]. Recognizing this, the
NASPGHAN Pancreas committee recommended that children with mild acute
pancreatitis may be benefit from early feeding (within 48 to 72 hours) either
by oral or enteral means to decrease length of hospital stay and risk of organ
dysfunction [18]. In this study, 24 of
the 28 cases was initially on NPO, with a mean length of NPO at 2.9 days. Thus,
majority (54%) was started on early feeding as defined in this study, as within
3 days. Contraindications to use the gut should be recognized such as ileus,
complex fistulae and abdominal compartment syndrome, thus for these cases, a
parenteral nutrition should be considered [18]. In our study, parenteral
nutrition was given in 2 of the cases only, although none of these
contraindications were noted from the review of charts.
Although, pediatric
acute pancreatitis generally follows a mild course, there is a proportion of
15% to 34% that develops into a severe form [20,21]. The natural course of AP
in children is still being investigated more closely in the INSPPIRE cohort,
and no good predictor score system is available for children [16], it was
important that severity classification specifically for children be defined.
Thus, a classification system was recently published by the NASPGHAN Pancreas
Committee in 2017 [8]. In this chart review, based on this classification,
there were 20 cases (71%) had mild disease, there were 7 cases (25%) with
moderately severe and only one (4%) who developed persistent organ dysfunction
who was classified as severe. Looking at the clinical and biochemical factors,
no statistically significant difference was seen between the group of mild
versus non-mild group (which consists both of moderately severe and severe
pancreatitis). The radiographic findings among the 2 groups was statistically
significant with a p value of 0.012. Local complications such as findings of
necrosis, pseudocysts and other fluid collections are part of the criteria for
moderately severe acute pancreatitis and hence reflected on the analysis, with
no normal imaging findings seen on non-mild cases. Findings of enlarged or
edematous pancreas were both seen among the two severity groups and has no
statistically significant difference among them (p=0.667). Findings pertaining
to other organs, such as gallstones, ascites and fatty liver were also seen in
both groups. Presence of gallstones occurred more frequently in the non-mild
group at 50% compared to the mild group at 5% and this difference was
statistically significant with p value of 0.028. Further sub analysis was not
done due to the small sample size that joint effects of variation will not
assessed accurately. The timing of initiation of feeding, length of hospital
and outcome did not produce a statistically significant difference between mild
and non-mild groups.
Outcome is highly
dependent on the severity with those with severe forms leading to mortality
[20,21]. In this study, only one case died, with mortality rate of 3.6% which agrees
with the available data ranging from 3 – 11% [15]. The single mortality was an 8-year-old
female, obese, without any other known co-morbid conditions who presented with
a 2-day history of severe abdominal pain and vomiting who was classified as
severe acute pancreatitis. No other co-morbid condition was noted, and no
trauma nor drug intake use seen on review. The only risk factor seen was
obesity and on ultrasonography done 2 days prior to admission to this
institution, showed only fatty liver and ascites. Of all the cases included in
this study, only this case had surgical intervention with an initial impression
of acute appendicitis. However, intraoperative findings showed hemorrhagic
peritoneal fluid with noted fat saponification at the omentum and mesenteric
wall. Post-operative diagnosis was hemorrhagic pancreatitis. Post operatively,
the patient continued to decline with persistence of multi-organ failure.
Although no evidence of pancreatic necrosis was seen on an initial imaging
finding, ultrasonography has low sensitivity in detecting areas of necrosis for
which a contrast-enhanced computed tomography would be indicated. Adult
literature suggests that early intervention in pancreatic necrosis leads to
increased morbidity and mortality and hence preferably be delayed for at least
4 weeks from presentation. Indications for acute surgical intervention include
abdominal trauma where patient instability and/or search for associated injury
to other organs is occurring [18].
In terms of the other clinical outcome seen,
clinical improvement was further subclassified into those with complete
(enzymatic and/or radiologic) resolution and those with complete (enzymatic
and/or radiologic) resolution. Although a repeat pancreatic enzyme
determination and imaging is not routinely done, most had repeat measurements
of enzymes until they are within acceptable level before discharge. Sixteen
cases or 59% were noted with complete resolution while the remaining were
discharged with one or both enzymes not yet returning to levels below 3 times
the upper limit. Sex, nutritional status, presence of co-morbidities, etiology,
imaging findings, timing of feeding, hospitalization length nor severity were
not statistically significant between the 2 types of clinical improvement outcomes.
However, age was noted to have statistically significantly difference of p
value 0.04 among those discharged with complete resolution compared to those
with incomplete resolution. Further regression analysis was not done due to
small sample size that joint effects of variations will not be accurately
assessed.
CONCLUSION
Acute pancreatitis in
the pediatric population has been gaining more recognition in the past decade
approaching an incidence of that in the adult population. However, there is much
to learn in the natural course and severity predictors in the pediatric
pancreatitis. Large multi-centered studies and database, consensus definitions,
severity classification which were done in the recent years were the initial
steps taken towards understanding pediatric pancreatitis. Acute Pancreatitis
was identified in 28 admissions during an 18-year period. It presented more
commonly in the adolescent age group, with slight male predominance, of normal
nutritional status and with no recognizable cause (idiopathic). In this study,
the recent consensus definitions and severity classifications were utilized to
compare groups and to check for possible associations. Of the factors included,
imaging findings (i.e. gallstones) and the 3-10 years old age group were found
have statistically significant difference in terms of having a mild vs non-mild
severity classification and type of clinical outcome on discharge,
respectively. These factors should be considered closely during management of
pediatric acute pancreatitis.
As limitation of a
retrospective chart review, further inquiries on additional pertinent findings
on history and laboratory parameters to explore cannot be made. The small
sample size restrained from executing further analysis that will be of value. A
multi-center study on the incidence and clinical profile and outcome is
recommended to obtain a better picture of the acute pancreatitis in Filipino
children to help clinicians in recognizing and decreasing the morbidity and
mortality of this disease.
REFERENCES: