Background: Infection cases caused by Multi-drug Resistant
Organisms (MDRO) have increased in the last few decades. Antimicrobial
resistance is responsible for 30% of neonatal mortality worldwide. Preterm
birth discovered as independent risk factor for MDRO in neonates associated
with immature immune system. However, other studies suggested conversely.
Aims: To investigate the relationship between preterm birth and the incidence of MDRO in septic neonates at Dr. Moewardi Hospital Surakarta.
Methods: A retrospective analytic observational study with case control design conducted. The subjects were septic neonates proven by blood cultures hospitalized during January to December 2021 at Dr. Moewardi hospital Surakarta. This study used SPSS 25.0 with Chi Square bivariate analysis followed by multivariate logistic regression analysis.
Results: The subjects were 60 neonates, consisted of 30 MDRO and 30 non-MDRO neonates. There were 21 MDRO neonates (70%) born prematurely and 8 premature neonates (26,6%) in non-MDRO group. Chi square bivariate analysis found that low birth weight (OR=3.755, 95%CI=1.239–11.385, p=0.017), preterm birth (OR=6.417, 95%CI=2.084-19.755, p=0.001) and duration of antibiotic administration >7 days (OR=5.231, 95%CI=1.657-16.515, p=0.003) had p<0.05. Results continued with multivariate logistic regression analysis showed that preterm birth (OR=7.632, 95%CI=1.158-50,293, p=0.035) and duration of antibiotic administration >7 days (OR=3.939, 95%CI=1.106-14.032, p=0.034) had significant correlation with the incidence of MDRO in neonates.
Limitations: We had not been able to analyze medical personnel’s hand hygiene adherence because the data used is retrospective data.
Conclusion: Preterm birth was associated with the incidence of MDRO in neonates at Dr. Moewardi hospital Surakarta.
Keywords: MDRO, preterm birth, neonates, neonatal sepsis, antimicrobial resistance
INTRODUCTION
Infection cases caused by
Multi-drug Resistant Organisms (MDRO) have increased in the last few decades.
This requires more attention because alternative antibiotics as a treatment are
limited.1,2 Inappropriate administration of antibiotics can affect
the worsening of the patient's condition. This can be life-threatening and
increase in the burden of patients’ treatment costs.3,4
Based on the International
Expert Proposal for Interim Standard Definitions for Acquired Resistance, MDRO
is a condition which a bacterial isolate is resistant to at least one agent of
antibiotic from ≥ 3 classes of antibiotics from these following antimicrobial
categories: Carbapenems, Penicillins, Broad-spectrum Cephalosporins,
Monobactams, Aminoglycosides, Fluoroquinolones, Chloramphenicol, folate pathway
inhibitors, Tetracyclines, Macrolides and Glycopeptides.1,5,6
Neonates are susceptible to
infectious diseases because their immune system has not fully developed yet.
Therefore, neonates at risk for developing antimicrobial resistance which
causes high morbidity and mortality compared to the older children.4,7 Antimicrobial resistance has
been reported to be responsible for around 30% mortality of neonatal sepsis
worldwide.8,9
There are various risk
factors for MDRO infection in neonates in several studies. Previous studies
have identified extremely low birth weight, preterm birth, and long-term
antibiotic administration as independent risk factors associated with the increase
of antimicrobial resistance incidences.3 The preterm baby has an
immature immune system, lack of innate and adaptive immunity, which can be
further linked by various factors associated with preterm birth. The immune
system of preterm neonates has a smaller pool of monocytes and neutrophils,
impaired ability of these cells to destroy pathogens, and lower production of
cytokines that limit T-cell activation and reduced capability to destruct
bacteria and detect viruses in cells, compared to full-term neonates.
Intrauterine inflammation is a major contributor to preterm birth, and leads to
premature immune activation and cytokine production. This can induce immune
tolerance which leads to decreased immune function in newborns.10-12
Thantrimontrichai et al (2019) found that preterm birth as an independent risk
factor for the occurrence of gram-negative rods MDRO associated with immature
immune system.7
However, in a study by
Giuffre et al (2016) stated otherwise that preterm birth was not the
independent risk factor for MDRO in neonates. The absence of a significant
association may indicate cross-transmission during treatment in the Neonatal
Intensive Care Unit (NICU).12 Study of Tsai et al (2014) also stated
that premature birth was not the independent risk factor for the incidence of
MDRO in neonates, but they found that the history of administration of
third-generation cephalosporin antibiotics and carbapenems as the independent
risk factor.3 Other risk factors of MDRO were Length of Stay (LOS),
history of invasive procedures, using of mechanical ventilators, APGAR scores,
duration of central venous access, parenteral nutrition, and formula feeding.13,14
This
study was purposed to determine the relationship between preterm birth and the
incidence of MDRO in neonates at Dr. Moewardi hospital Surakarta.
Methods
This research was a
retrospective analytic observational study with case control design. Data
collection was obtained from patient’s medical record data. The subjects were
neonates who were treated in the neonatal High Care Unit (HCU) and NICU
diagnosed neonatal sepsis proven by patient's blood cultures found organism at
Dr. Moewardi hospital Surakarta during the hospitalization period from January
to December 2021. Sampling was carried out by purposive sampling. This study
used patient medical record data. The sample size was calculated using the
sample size formula for multivariate analysis involving ≥ 6 predictors with formula
is shown below:
n > 10 m
where,
n = minimum sample size or minimum number of subjects
m = number of variables studied
In this study, six
variables were used, consisting of one independent variable and five
confounding variables which were included in the study, so that the minimum
sample size in this study required a minimum of 60 subjects.
Inclusion criteria included
data on gestational age at birth, duration of previous antibiotic administration,
LOS, using of invasive mechanical ventilators, birth weight, and APGAR scores from
patient’s medical record data. Incomplete medical record data have been
excluded. Medical record data that fulfilled the inclusion criteria divided
into two groups, namely the MDRO group as the case group and the non-MDRO group
as the control group. This study used SPSS 25.0 with Chi Square bivariate
analysis followed by multivariate logistic regression analysis with a p value
<0.05 was statistically significant.
Results
This study involved sixty
neonates diagnosed as neonatal sepsis proven by blood culture found organisms
at Dr. Moewardi Surakarta during the hospitalize period from January to
December 2021. There were thirty neonates with MDRO and thirty non-MDRO neonates.
The characteristics of the subjects in both groups are shown in Table 1.
The most common organism
found was Klebsiella pneumoniae both in the MDRO group there were ten neonates
(33.3%) and also in the non-MDRO group there were three neonates (10%). Other
Table 1. Characteristic of subjects
Variables |
Resistance |
p-value |
|
MDRO |
Non-MDRO |
||
Gender |
0.438 |
||
Males |
14 (46.7%) |
17 (56.7%) |
|
Females |
16 (53.3%) |
13 (43.3%) |
|
Birth weight |
0.014* |
||
Very Low (VLBW) (<1500 g) |
15 (50.0%) |
5 (16.7%) |
|
Low (LBW) (<2500 g) |
8 (26.7%) |
9 (30.0%) |
|
Normal (NBW) (>2500 – 3999 g) |
7 (23.3%) |
16 (53.3%) |
|
Gestational Age (weeks) |
0.006* |
||
Extremely
preterm (<28) |
1 (3.3%) |
0 (0.0%) |
|
Very preterm (28-<32) |
9 (30.0%) |
2 (6.7%) |
|
Moderate to late preterm
(32-<37) |
11 (36.7%) |
6 (20.0%) |
|
At term (37-<42) |
9 (30.0%) |
22 (73.3%) |
|
Delivery |
0.598 |
||
Spontaneous |
13 (43.3%) |
11 (36.7%) |
|
Cesarean |
17 (56.7%) |
19 (63.3%) |
|
Length of Stay (LOS) |
0.067 |
||
> 15 days |
16 (53.3%) |
9 (30.0%) |
|
< 15 days |
14 (46.7%) |
21 (70.0%) |
|
Outcome |
0.184 |
||
Mortality |
21 (70.0%) |
16 (53.3%) |
|
Survived |
9 (30.0%) |
14 (46.7%) |
|
Mechanical ventilation |
0.781 |
||
Invasive mechanical ventilation |
9 (30.0%) |
10 (33.3%) |
|
Without invasive mechanical
ventilation |
21 (70.0%) |
20 (66.7%) |
|
Duration of antibiotic
administration |
0.003* |
||
> 7 days |
17 (56.7%) |
6 (20.0%) |
|
< 7 days |
13 (43.3%) |
80.0%) |
*p-value <0.05
organisms found in the
group of neonates with MDRO were Staphylococcus haemolyticus (16.7%), Acinetobacter
baumannii (13.3%), and Staphylococcus hominis (13.3%), and the rest
being other types of organisms with a percentage of less than 10%. In the group
of non-MDRO neonates, many fungi were found, namely Candida parapsilosis
(30.0%), followed by Klebsiella pneumoniae organisms (10.0%) and the
rest were other types of organisms with a percentage of less than 10%. The species
of organisms found are shown in Table 2.
Table 2. Organisms isolated from blood
culture
Organisms |
Resistance |
|
MDRO |
Non-MDRO |
|
Klebsiella pneumoniae |
10 (33.3%) |
3 (10.0%) |
Acinetobacter baumannii |
4 (13.3%) |
2 (6.7%) |
Citrobacter koseri |
1 (3.3%) |
0 (0.0%) |
Enterobacter cloacae |
2 (6.7%) |
0 (0.0%) |
Enterobacter faecalis |
1 (3.3%) |
2 (6.7%) |
Pseudomonas aeruginosa |
1 (3.3%) |
2 (6.7%) |
Pseudomonas stutzeri |
0 (0.0%) |
2 (6.7%) |
Staphylococcus aureus |
0 (0.0%) |
2 (6.7%) |
Staphylococcus epidermidis |
2 (6.7%) |
0 (0.0%) |
Staphylococcus haemolyticus |
5 (16.7%) |
0 (0.0%) |
Staphylococcus hominis |
4 (13.3%) |
2 (6.7%) |
Staphylococcus
saprophyticus |
0 (0.0%) |
1 (3.3%) |
Streptokokkus agalactiae |
0 (0.0%) |
1 (3.3%) |
Acinetobacter spp |
0 (0.0%) |
1 (3.3%) |
Acinetobacter wolfii |
0 (0.0%) |
1 (3.3%) |
Eschericia coli |
0 (0.0%) |
1 (3.3%) |
Fungus |
|
|
Candida haemulonii |
0 (0.0%) |
1 (3.3%) |
Candida parapsilosis |
0 (0.0%) |
9 (30.0%) |
The bivariate analysis
showed a significant correlation between the incidence of MDRO in neonates on
LBW group (OR= 3.755, 95%CI=1.239–11.385, p=0.017), preterm birth group (OR=6.417,
95%CI=2.084-19.755, p=0.001), and duration of antibiotic administration >7
days group (OR=5.231, 95%CI=1.657-16.515, p=0.003) were shown in Table 3. To
discover the dominant variable at risk for incidence of MDRO, a multivariate
logistic regression analysis was performed.
Table 3. Bivariate analysis of factors associated with the incidence of MDRO
Variables |
Resistance |
OR (95% CI) |
p-value |
|
MDRO |
Non-MDRO |
|||
Sex |
|
|
|
|
Males |
14 (46.7%) |
17 (56.7%) |
0.669 (0.242-1.852) |
0.438 |
Females |
16 (53.3%) |
13 (43.3%) |
Ref. |
|
Birth weight |
|
|
||
LBW/VLBW (<2500 g) |
23 (76.7%) |
14 (46.7%) |
3.755 (1.239-11.385) |
0.017* |
NBW (>2500 – 3999 g) |
7 (23.3%) |
16 (53.3%) |
Ref. |
|
Gestational age (weeks) |
|
|
||
Preterm (<37) |
21 (70.0%) |
8 (26.7%) |
6.417 (2.084-19.755) |
0.001* |
Aterm (37-<42) |
9 (30.0%) |
22 (73.3%) |
Ref. |
|
Delivery |
|
|
|
|
Spontaneous |
13 (43.3%) |
11 (36.7%) |
1.321 (0.469- 3.721) |
0.598 |
Cesarean |
17 (56.7%) |
19 (63.3%) |
Ref. |
|
Length of Stay (LOS) |
|
|
|
|
>15 days |
16 (53.3%) |
9 (30.0%) |
2.667 (0.924- 7.699) |
0.067 |
<15 days |
14 (46.7%) |
21 (70.0%) |
Ref. |
|
Mechanical ventilation |
|
|
|
|
Invasive mechanical ventilation |
9 (30.0%) |
10 (33.3%) |
0 .857 (0 .288- 2.547) |
0.781 |
Without invasive mechanical
ventilation |
21 (70.0%) |
20 (66.7%) |
Ref. |
|
Duration of antibiotic
administration |
|
|
||
> 7 days |
17 (56.7%) |
6 (20.0%) |
5.231 (1.657-16.515) |
0.003* |
< 7 days |
13 (43.3%) |
24 (80.0%) |
Ref. |
|
*p-value <0.05
The multivariate analysis showed a significant correlation
between preterm birth (OR=7.632, 95%CI=1.158-50.293, p=0.035) and duration of
antibiotics administration >7 days (OR=3.939, 95%CI=1.106-14.032, p=0.034)
with the incidence of MDRO in neonates were shown in Table 4.
Table 4. Logistic regression multivariate analysis of factors associated with the incidence of MDRO*
Variables |
OR (95%CI) |
p-value |
LBW/VLBW |
0.540 (0.077-3.797) |
0.535 |
Preterm birth |
7.632 (1.158-50.293) |
0.035* |
Duration of antibiotic
administration
> 7 days |
3.939 (1.106-14.032) |
0.034* |
*Only variables with
p-value <0.05
The description of the
APGAR score based on the incidence of MDRO in this study used the Mann Whitney
test. Mann Whitney test was
conducted to see whether there was a difference in APGAR scores in the MDRO
group and the non-MDRO group. Our study found that the 1st minute
APGAR score had p value=0.662 (p>0.05), the 5th minute got p
value=0.514 (p>0.05) and the 10th minute had p value=0.306
(p>0.05) were not significantly related to the incidence of MDRO in neonates
at Dr. Moewardi hospital Surakarta is shown in Table 5.
Table 5. APGAR scores based on
incidence of MDRO
Variable |
Resistance |
p-value |
|
MDRO |
Non-MDRO |
||
1st minute APGAR score |
|
|
0.662 |
Mean +SD |
5.37 +1.85 |
5.60 +1.65 |
|
Median
(min-max) |
6.00 (2.00-8.00) |
6.00 (3.00-8.00) |
|
5th minute APGAR score |
|
|
0.514 |
Mean +SD |
6.60 +1.57 |
6.97 +1.35 |
|
Median (min-max) |
7.00 (3.00-9.00) |
7.00 (4.00-9.00) |
|
10th minute APGAR score |
|
|
0.306 |
Mean +SD |
7.80 +1.42 |
8.30 +1.02 |
|
Median
(min-max) |
8.00 (4.00-10.00) |
8.00 (6.00-10.00) |
|
Discussion
Our study found that the
most common types of organisms in the group of neonatal sepsis patients with
MDRO were Klebsiella pneumoniae (33.3%), Staphylococcus haemolyticus
(16.7%), Acinetobacter baumannii (13.3%), and Staphylococcus hominis
(13.3%), and the rest were other types of organisms with a percentage of less
than 10%. This is different from the research by Estiningsih et al in 2016, it
was observed that the bacterias that infected NICU patients at dr. Soeradji
Tirtonegoro hospital were Pseudomonas sp (30.4%), Klebsiella sp
(23.9%), Serratia sp (15.2%), and Enterobacter sp (15.2%). This
differences because each hospital has a different pattern of organisms.15,16 In our study, it was observed
that the Klebsiella pneumonia was most commonly organism found in MDRO
patients where the organisms were gram-negative bacterium which is in line with
study by Litzow et al (2009) in the Philippines, Tsai et al (2014) in Taiwan,
Thatrimontrical et al (2019) in Thailand and research by Giuffre et al (2016)
in Italy which stated that there was a tendency for a rapid increase in
gram-negative bacterial infections that cause MDRO conditions in neonatal
patients treated in the NICU.3,7,13,17 Our study also was in line with the research by Ballot et al in 2019 in
Johannesburg, South Africa and Yuse et al (2016) in Jordan, that the most
commonly found organism was Klebsiella pneumoniae.18,19
Based on the gestational
age in the bivariate analysis between preterm birth and the incidence of MDRO
in neonates in our study, the results obtained OR = 6.417 (95%CI=2.084 –19.755)
with p=0.001 (p <0.05) then followed by multivariate analysis with the
results obtained OR=7.632 (95%CI=1.158-50.293) with value of p = 0.035 (p
<0.05) which mean that preterm birth had risk of 7.632 times the incidence
of MDRO, thus preterm birth was one of the dominant factors at risk of MDRO
incidence. Our research result is in
line with Begum et al's study in 2016 where premature infants had a correlation
with the incidence of sepsis, both early onset and late onset sepsis due to an
immature immune system which was at risk for MDRO.10,13,19 In the
2016 study by Giuffre et al, it was stated diverse that preterm birth was not the
independent risk factor for MDRO incidence in neonates. The absence of a
significant association might indicate cross-transmission phenomenon during
treatment in the NICU.13
In the bivariate analysis
between the duration of antibiotics administration >7 days and the incidence
of MDRO in neonates in our study, the results obtained OR=5.231
(95%CI=1.657–16.515) with p=0.003 (p <0.05). Then proceed by multivariate
analysis and then obtained OR=3.939 (95%CI=1,106-14,032) with p=0.034
(p<0.05) which mean that duration of antibiotics administration >7 days
had risk of 3.939 times the incidence of MDRO, thus the duration of antibiotics
administration >7 days was one of the dominant risk factors for the
occurrence of MDRO.
Our research results are in
accordance with the study of Giuffre et al in 2016 which stated that the
average duration of administration of Ampicillin-Gentamicin antibiotics was 7.4
days as the independent risk factor for MDRO in neonates.13 The
bacterial selective pressure comes from the use of antibiotic doses. When the doses
of antibiotics used reach or are close to sublethal doses, the selective
pressure of antibiotics can force changes in the body's behavior, physiology
and biochemistry. Genes and proteins in the expression of resistant bacteria
will change, the body's protective and immune defenses will gradually weaken,
and the risk of MDRO increases.2
Based on birth weight in
bivariate analysis between LBW/VLBW and MDRO incidences in neonates in our
study, the results obtained OR=3.755 (95%CI=1.239–11.385) with p=0.017
(p<0.05). Furthermore, multivariate analysis was performed to obtain
OR=0.540 (95%CI=0.077-3.797) with p value=0.535 (p>0.05) which mean that LBW
was not the dominant factor at risk for MDRO. Our results were not the similiar
as the study by Ballot et al in 2019 which stated that there was a correlation
between the incidence of LBW, prematurity, maternal HIV infection and
oxygenation in the initial 28 days with the incidence of multidrug resistant Enterobacteriace.21
Intrauterine growth disorders could affect birth weight and development of the
respiratory, cardiovascular, neurological, hematological and immunological
systems. Neonates with VLBW have the highest risk of infection due to low
immunity.22
This difference might be
due to the large discrepancy in the number of subjects in that study were 2437
neonates, while the total subjects of our study were 60 neonates.
LOS in the MDRO group
obtained a value of OR=2.667 (95%CI=0.924–7.699) p=0.067 (p>0.05) which mean
that there was no significant correlation between LOS and the incidence of
MDRO. This is not in line with the study of Abdel-Hady et al which stated that
the total number of days in the hospital was an independent risk factor for Klebsiella
pneumoniae caused infection of Extended Spectrum Beta-Lactamase (ESBL).
The study said that the hospital environment played an important role in the
transmission of these pathogens, especially the spread from medical personnels.22,23
This difference may be due to the group of MDRO neonates in our study who
obtained LOS <15 days because there was mortality of 21 neonates in MDRO
group, while in the non-MDRO group there were 16 neonates died.
In the using of invasive
mechanical ventilation in the MDRO group, the value was OR=0.857
(95%CI=0.288–2.547) p=0.781 (p > 0.05) which mean that there was no
significant relationship between the using of invasive mechanical ventilation
with MDRO incidence. Our study is different from the research by Wang et al in
2020 and Tsai et al in 2014 which stated that there was an effect of using
invasive mechanical ventilation on the incidence of MDRO, with the longer the
duration of ventilator use, then the higher the incidence of MDRO. This might
happen because both the group of patients with MDRO and not MDRO used only
small number of ventilators in our study. This may be due to differences in the
number of research subjects which are very different where in the 2014 Tsai’s
study with total sample size 1106 neonates and differences in research methods
where the study was a prospective cohort study conducted for eight years.2,3
APGAR score in the 1st
minute had p=0.662 (p>0.05), in the 5th minute got p=0.514
(p>0.05) and in the 10th minute had p=0.306 (p>0.05). All
three there were no significant difference between the MDRO group and the
non-MDRO group, thus the 1st minute, 5th minute, and 10th
minute APGAR scores were not associated with the MDRO incidence, although the
APGAR scores of MDRO group tended to be lower (mean score 1-5-10 minutes =
5.37–6.6–7.8) compared to the non-MDRO group (mean score 1-5-10 minutes =
5.60–6.97–8.3) in our study. This is not in line with the study of Geyesus et
al (2017) in Egypt which stated that the APGAR score in the 5th
minute with a score <7 was an independent risk factor for sepsis which then led
to an MDRO condition in neonates.19 This difference occurred perhaps
because in our study the average APGAR score obtained in both the MDRO and
non-MDRO groups at 5th minutes both obtained a score of <7.
The incidence of MDRO
caused by nosocomial hospital infections commonly referred to as
hospital-acquired infections (HAI's) which one of the preventions of this
condition is isolation precautions that is evaluation of hand hygiene adherence,
which can be a risk factor for MDRO incidence in neonates.16,25,26 The
longer the patient was hospitalized, the exposure to HAI's will increase as
well as the MDRO incidence in neonates..26 In our study, we had not been
able to analyze medical personnel’s hand hygiene adherence because the data
used is retrospective data which there was no data on hand hygiene compliance.
Preterm birth (OR=7.632, 95%CI=1.158-50.293,
p value=0.035) and duration of antibiotics administration >7 days (OR=3.939,
95%CI=1.106-14.032, p value=0.034) had significant correlation with the
incidence of MDRO in neonatal patients at Dr. Moewardi hospital Surakarta. Klebsiella
pneumoniae was the most common organism found to cause MDRO incidence in
neonatal patients at Dr. Moewardi hospital Surakarta.
Acknowledgment
The authors are grateful
and thanks to Pediatric Department of Dr. Moewardi Hospital, Surakarta which
provide facilities for the authors.
Conflict of interest
None declared.
Role of the funding source
The authors received no
specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial, or
not-for-profit sectors.
References