Dengue fever is one of the most important emerging vector-borne viral
diseases. There are four serotypes of dengue viruses, each of which is capable
of causing self-limited dengue fever or even life-threatening dengue
hemorrhagic fever and dengue shock syndrome. The aim of this study was to
evaluate the sonographic findings in serologically proven dengue fever
patients. This cross sectional observational study included 438 serologically
confirmed children with dengue fever admitted in Pediatric Department benazir
Bhutto Hospital during 2019 outbreak. The participants were clinically and
serologically evaluated against NS1 antigen, IgM and IgG antibody. These
patients also underwent USG abdomen and chest within the first week of the
illness. Among 438 dengue serology positive children, 254 were male children
(58%), and 184 were female children (42%). The age of the children ranged from
03 months to 12 years, with a mean age of 8.03 years (SD ±3.13 years). 254
(58%) children were classified having uncomplicated dengue fever. Dengue
hemorrhagic fever developed in 119 (27.1%) children while 65 (14.9%) children
went in to dengue shock syndrome. Uncomplicated Dengue fever had no significant
finding on ultrasonography. Free fluid in body cavities like ascites, pleural
effusion was noted in almost 100% of cases having DHF or DSS followed by
Thickening of gall bladder wall (19 % in DHF and 63% in DSS) hepatomegaly (30%
in DHF and 95% in DSS) and Splenomegaly (9%in DHF and 20% in DSS). Findings in
ultrasonography, suggested that there is more tendency of plasma leakage and
hepato-spleenomegaly in infants and 9-12 years age group. GB wall thickening
was seen in most of the patients whose platelet count was <50,000 (50.7%).
Ascites/pleural effusion (85%) and hepatomegaly (42.1%) were the other common
findings seen in patients whose platelet count was <50,000. In patients
whose platelet count was > 100,000, there were no significant ultrasonographic
findings except for hepatomegaly.
INTRODUCTION
A member of flavivirus
family, Dengue virus (serotypes DENV-1 to DENV-4), is responsible for the
highest disease burden of any arthropod-borne viral infection worldwide.The
global incidence of dengue has grown dramatically in recent decades.About half
of the worlds population is now at risk.The global incidence of Dengue has
grown dramatically in recent decades.Almost half of the world population is at
risk.There are estimated 100-400 million Dengue infections each year1
A high rate of Dengue infection is found in post monsoon months.2The
case fatality in Dengue is 1.143.Early and accurate diagnosis is
critical to reduce mortality 4,
Dengue can be diagnosed
clinically against predefined list of sign and symptoms and by detection of dengue specific antibodies ,non-structural
1 antigen or viral RNA by reverse transcriptase –polymerase chain reaction.5Viral
detection and serological conversion have been the main targets of diagnostic
assessment for many years. Ultrasound findings as
increased gall bladde wall thickness ,pleural efusion,ascities,hepatomegaly and
splenomegaly in clinically suspected dengue fever cases especially in endemic
areas are highly suggestive of dengue fever.7Third spacing of fluid
in various areas of body can occur in critical (plasma leak)phase of Dengue,
manifesting in subtle effusions and gall bladder wall congestion that may not
be evident on physical examination.8 Gall bladder wall thickening is
one of the most common findings in dengue fever.9 The common
ultrasound finding associated with severe dengue fever are gall bladder wall
thickening,ascities,pleural effusion,pericardial effusion,pericholecystic fluid
,hepatomegaly,splenomegaly and mesenteric adenopathy.1Ultrasound findings
of hepatomegaly,gall bladder wall edema ,right sided or bilateral pleural
effusion and ascities in patients with signs and symptoms of dengue fever
during an epidemic are virtually diagnostic of dengue fever.11Early
demonstration of serosal collection helps to grade dengue fever to severe
dengue fever and prioritize patients for critical care. 12
The aim of present
study was to evaluate the sonographic findings of dengue fever which may be
useful as an early diagnostic tool and to predict the severity pattern of the
disease.
materials and methods
This cross-sectional
observational study was carried out in the department of pediatrics, Benazir
Bhutto Hospital, Rawalpindi. 438 children age up to 12 years with serologically
confirmed dengue fever, admitted during the outbreak of 2019, were included in
this study. All these patients were clinically and serologically evaluated.
These patients also underwent USG abdomen and chest within the first week of
the illness. Based on the investigation results, patients were classified into
3 categories as per WHO guidelines: Dengue fever, Dengue Hemorrhagic fever and
Dengue shock syndrome. All patients were treated as per DEAG guidelines. The
results were tabulated and analyzed in SPSS24
results
During the
outbreak period of 6 months, 438 dengue serology positive children were
admitted, among which 254 were male children (58%), and 184 were female
children (42%). The age of the children ranged from 03 months to 12 years, with
a mean age of 8.03 years (SD ±3.13 years).
DEMOGRAPHIC
AND CLINICAL PRESENTATION OF DENGUE CASES |
||
Gender |
Frequency (n= 438) |
Percentage |
Male |
254 |
58 |
Female |
184 |
42 |
Age (Mean 8.03 years SD
±3.13 Years) |
||
Less than 1 year |
15 |
3.4 |
1-4 years |
78 |
17.8 |
5- 8 years |
114 |
26.1 |
9-12 years |
231 |
52.7 |
Each child was examined for ultrasound of abdomen, pelvis and chest for
detection of plasma leakage and free fluid accumulation in cavities. All the
children with final diagnosis of uncomplicated Dengue fever had no significant
finding on ultrasonography. Free fluid
in body cavities like ascites, pleural effusion was noted in almost 100% of
cases having DHF or DSS followed by Thickening of gall bladder wall (19 % in
DHF and 63% in DSS) hepatomegaly (30% in DHF and 95% in DSS), and Splenomegaly
(9%in DHF and 20% in DSS).
ULTRASONOGRAPHIC
FINDINGS |
||
USG FINDING |
NO OF PATIENTS |
PERCENTAGE |
·
Normal |
254 |
57.99 |
·
Gall
bladder with thickening |
63 |
14.38 |
·
Ascites/Pleural/Pelvic
fluid |
175 |
39.95 |
·
Hepatomegaly |
95 |
21.69 |
·
Splenomegaly |
24 |
5.48 |
·
Pericardial
effusion |
4 |
0.91 |
All children were classified according to DEAG-WHO criteria for severity
of dengue fever. 254 (58%) children were classified having uncomplicated dengue
fever. Dengue hemorrhagic fever developed in 119 (27.1%) children while 65
(14.9%) children went in to dengue shock syndrome. One child died of shock and
severe Respiratory distress and multi organ failure.
USG |
DHF (N=119) |
DSS (N=65) |
TOTAL (N=184) |
Abdominal/pleural/ pelvic
fluid |
110 (92.5%) |
65(100%) |
175(95%) |
Gall bladder wall edema |
22(19%) |
41(63%) |
63(34.3%) |
Hepatomegaly |
35(29.5%) |
60(92%) |
95(51.7%) |
Splenomegaly |
11(9.2%) |
13(20%) |
24 (13%) |
Pericardial Effusion |
1(0.8%) |
3(4.7%) |
4 (4.5%) |
Findings in ultrasonography, suggested that there is more tendency of
plasma leakage and hepato-spleenomegaly in infants and 9-12 years age group.
USG FINDING |
Less than 1
year (n=15) |
1-4 years (n=78) |
4-8 years (n=114) |
9-12 years (n=231) |
Normal (254) |
4 |
50 |
68 |
132 |
Gall bladder with
thickening (63) |
7 |
11 |
10 |
35 |
Abdominal/pleural/ pelvic
fluid (175) |
11 |
48 |
53 |
63 |
Hepatomegaly (95) |
8 |
21 |
24 |
42 |
Splenomegaly (24) |
4 |
4 |
6 |
11 |
Pericardial effusion (4) |
2 |
1 |
1 |
0 |
GB wall thickening was seen in most of the patients whose platelet count
was <50,000 (50.7%). Ascites/pleural effusion (85%) and hepatomegaly (42.1%)
were the other common findings seen in patients whose platelet count was
<50,000. In patients whose platelet count was > 100,000, there were no
significant ultrasonographic findings except for splenomegaly.
USG FINDING |
< 50,000 (N=67) |
50,000 –
100,000 (N=341) |
>100,000 (N=30) |
Normal (254) |
14 |
215 |
24 |
Gall bladder with
thickening (63) |
34 |
28 |
01 |
Ascites (175) |
57 |
111 |
2 |
Hepatomegaly (95) |
45 |
50 |
0 |
Splenomegaly (24) |
14 |
07 |
03 |
Pericardial effusion (4) |
3 |
1 |
0 |
DISCUSSIONS
There are estimated
100-400 million Dengue infections each
year(1). Pakista has experienced large epidemics of
dengue fever.A comparison of data during these epidemics indicates a shift from
mild to more severe disease which could be interpreted as an epidemilogical
transition pattern in the Couyntry.13 Detailed knowledge of clinical
symptoms and Laboratory feature is essential for appropriate triage.14
As Serological diagnosis is confirmatory of
dengue and includes direct methods such as virus isolation and NS1antigen
detection and indirect methods such as IgM and IgG antibody detection15.
As serological diagnosis takes some time to reflect the results, sonography has
an increasingly important role as sonography is a readily available and
cost-effective method for the diagnosis, which helps improve the management of
patients of dengue.
The aim of
present study was to evaluate the role of sonographic findings as early
diagnostic modality in children with dengue fever and
to predict the severity of disease in terms of complications.In present study,
male predominance was seen with 58 % male cases to 42% females with male to
female ratio of1.4:1. A study by Manoj Kumar et al has found a similar male to
female ratio of 1.54:1 in all sero positive cases.16while the study
of Srinivasa et al.17the ratio of male to female was 1.13:1. The sex
distribution is also consistent with a study
by Thakur S et al shows dengue fever occurs more in male sex18.
The
ultrasonographic findings showed pleural effusion and ascites in 137 (39.9%)
cases, hepatomegaly in 95 (21.69%) cases, gall bladder thickening in 63 (14.4%)
cases and splenomegaly in 24 (5.5%) cases. Four cases have evidence for
pericardial effusion.
Overall 181
(42%) out of 438 cases had one or more of the positive finding in
ultrasonography. This clearly shows that Ultrasound can be used as an early,
non-invasive and economical diagnostic tool. In the study by Srinivasa et al.17,
72% of the cases had ultrasound findings in the form of either hepatomegaly or
gall bladder wall thickening. The ultrasound findings showed gall bladder wall
thickening in 30.5%, in a study by Quiroz-Moreno et al.19
Gallbladder thickening was seen in 92.85% of the patients in severe Dengue
fever And 45 %patients of non Severe Dengue fever, Parmar J et al.20
In clinically Confirmed DHF cases finding of Gall bladder thickness >3mm to
5mm with 93.8% sensitivity can be used as a criterion for identifying DHF
patients at high risk of developing hypovolemic shock. 21.A
thickened Gall bladder wall is defined as >3mm(9) In our study, GB wall thickening was seen in
most of the patients whose platelet count was <50,000 (50.7%).
Ascites/pleural effusion (85%) and hepatomegaly (42.1%) were the other common
findings seen in patients whose platelet count was <50,000. In patients
whose platelet count was > 100,000, there were no significant
ultrasonographic findings except for splenomegaly.In one study ascities 93.8%
gall mladder wall thickening 64.8% right pleural effusion 78.7% left pleural
effusion 64.1%,bilateral pleural effusion 64.15,hepatomegaly 28% splenomegaly 42.6%
pericardial effusion 1.3% were found.22
In our
study pleural effusion or ascites was apparent on clinical examination in some
of the cases, but sonographyhelped in diagnosing all of them. This also aided
in early initiation of management modules for the treatment of DHF and DSS. All
the cases which went into hypotension and shock showed pleural effusion and or
ascities and gall bladder wall thickening,. The early initiation of specific
treatment and management in these cases greatly helped in mortality reduction
at our hospital. Only one child out of 438 cases expired in our hospital due to
dengue shock syndrome and its complications including multi organ failure. So
this study clearlydemonstrates the importance of ultrasonography in the
accurate and complete clinical evaluation of dengue fever.
CONCLUSION
USG should be
considered as a first-line imaging modality in all children with suspected
dengue fever to detect early signs suggestive of the disease progression along
with obtaining serologic confirmation tests.
REFERENCES
1. Dengue and Severe Dengue World Health
Organization Fact Sheet.2 march 2020.https://apps.who.int
2. Abdullah,Ali S,Salman M et al.Dengue
out breaks in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa(KPK)Pakistan In 2017:An Integrated Disease
Surveillance and Response System(IDSRS),based report.Pol J
Microbiol.2019;68(1):115-119.
3. Law G K-K,Ogston SA,Yong M-M,et
al.Global Dengue Death Before and after the New World Health Organization 2009
Case Classification: A Systematic Review and Meta-Regression Analysis.Acta Trop
2018 Jun;182:237-245.
4. Hassan S,Jamdar SM,Alalowi M et
al.Dengue Virus:A global human threat: Review of literature. J Int SOC Prev
Community Dent.2016 Jan-Feb;6(1):1-6.
5. Raafat N,Blacksell SD,Maude RJ.A review
of dengue diagnostics and implications for surveillance and control. Trans R
Soc Trop Med Hyg.2019 Nov;113(11):653-660.
6. Muller DA,Depelsenaire ACI,Young
PR.Clinical and Laboratory Diagnosis of Dengue Virus Infection.J Infest
Dis.2017 Mar 1;2015(2):S89-S 95.
7. Parmar J,Mohan C,Kumar GP,Vora M. Ultra
sound is not use full as a screening tool for dengue fever.Pol J
radiol.2017;82:693-700.
8. Shah S,Rolfe R,Henostroza G,Seas
C.Ultrasound findings of Plasma Leakage in Dengue Fever.Am J trop Med Hyg.2018
dec;99(6):1362-1363
9. Parmar JP.Mohan C,Vora M.Patterns of Gall
Bladder Wall Thickening in Dengue
Fever:A mirror of Severity of
Disease.Ultrassound Int Open .2017 Apr;3(2):E 76-E81.
10. Pothapregada S,Kullu P,Kamalakannan
B,Thulas -ingam M.Is Ultra sound are use full Tool to predict Severe Dengue
Infection?Indian J Pediatr.2016Jun ;83(6):500-4.
11. Chandak S,Kumar A.Can Radiology Play a
Role in Early Diagnosis of Dengue Fever.N Am J Med Sci.2016 Feb;8(2):100-105.
12. Krishnaveni N,Sarda B,Vasudhara N,Padma
K.Ultrasound as Screening Modality in Management of Fever Cases in Dengue
Epidemic.Afr J Radiol 2017;24(2):135-41.
13. Haider Z,Ahmed FZ,Mahmood A et
al.Dengue Fever in Pakistan :A Paradigm Shift, Changing Epidemiology and
Clinical Pattern.Perspect Public Health 2015Nov;135(6):294-8.
14. Tavakolipoor P,Schmidt,Chanosit
J,Burchard D, Jordan S.Clinical features and laboratory findings of Dengue
Fever in Germen travelers :A Single
–Centre Retrospective Analysis.Travel Med Infect Dis 2016 Jan-Feb;14(1):39-44
15. Dhooria S. et al. “Clinical profile and
outcome in children of dengue hemorrhagic fever in north India.” Iran J
Pediatr. Sep 2008; vol 18 (No.3): 222-228.
16. Kumar M,Verma RK,Mishra B. Prevalence
of Dengue Fever in Western Uttar Paradesh,India:A Gender-Based study.Int J Appl
Basic Med Res.2020 Jan-March;10(1):8-11.
17. Srinivasa S, Nawab T, Nair CC. Clinical
profile and ultasonogaphic findings in children with dengue fever. Current
Pediatrics. 2014;18(2).
18. Thulkar S, Sharma S, Srivastava DN,
Sharma SK, Berry M, Pandey RM et al. Sonographic findings in grade III dengue
hemorrhagic fever in adults. J Clin Ultrasound 2000; 28: 34-37.
19. Quiroz-Moreno R, Mendez GF, Ovando-
Rivera KM. Clinical Utility of ultrasound in the identification of dengue
hemorrhagi fever. Rev Med inst Mex SeguroSoc 2006 44(3): 243-348.
20. ParmarJ,VaraM,MohanC et al.”Honeycomb”pattern
of gall bladder wall thickening –A forward step in early diagnosis of `Severe
Dengue Fever”.Indian J Radiol Imaging 2019 Jan-Mar;29(1):14-18.
21. Setiawan MW, Samsi TK, Pool TN
,Sugianto D, Wulur H. Gallbladder wall thickening in dengue hemorrhagic fever:
an ultrasonographic Study. J Cin Ultrasound 1995; 23(6): 357-362.
22. ParmarJ,VaraM,MohanC et
al.”Honeycomb”pattern of gall bladder wall thickening –A forward step in early
diagnosis of `Severe Dengue Fever”.Indian J Radiol Imaging 2019 Jan-Mar;29(1):14-18.
23. Nagalu H,Papireddygari VK,Reddy PRV et al.Role of ultrasonography in
diagnosis and evaluation of dengue fever.Int. j.anat.radiol.surg.2017
Oct;6(4):Ro 52-Ro56.